Quite enjoyed everything about it. Haven't really heard much word of mouth about the sequel.
Then you'll like the sequel. It's very much just '...and the continuing adventures of Henry.' If you liked the first game, it's just more of that. I mean, it's tightened up. Looks a little better. Has more overall polish to the mechanics and functionality. But it's fundamentally the same gameplay. I enjoyed the story a fair bit. The side quests are, in my opinion, mostly better in this one than in the first one. Voice acting is still great.
There's even a secret ending you can get where you save Bohemia but die immediately -- full on Game Over screen. Which was honestly pretty hilarious.
So yes. In my opinion, it's just KCD1 but better in basically every way. Anyone looking for another hundred hours with Henry should be pretty happy. I will say that I wish I'd waited to start it until the two current DLCs came out (I have the gold edition, so I get all three - the last of which comes out this month). The first DLC is great for being able to paint shields, and has a really fun story. But the second DLC is fantastic if for no other reason than it gives you some really pretty swords and your own house you can customize and dump money into. Being able to fast-travel to your house AND have basically all the things you need right there (wash-tub for clothes, free food, bed, chest, forge, etc) is a game changer. But I'd already beaten the game when the DLC came out.
On the other hand, it was fun to unlock tons of stuff for the house immediately because I had like 145,000 groshen when I started the DLC.
I DID get the 'kind of bad ending' (I didn't know there were alternate endings), so I'll probably end up re-playing the game at some point. I played the first one twice, so stands to reason I should play the second one twice. But yeah, if you're the type that wants to do one good playthrough and call it done, beware that you can get a SOMEWHAT bad ending if you spend the game killing and stealing. I won't spoil it beyond that.
@Damien will be thrilled to learn that one of the cohosts is the critic whose Ghost of Yotei criticism I shared on the last page.
That guy is super cool. Big fan.
But I mean, yeah. It's tough to know what to do anymore. Sometimes it feels like the only way to be true to my own ethics is to just not buy anything from anyone anymore because everyone at every level fucking sucks. Horrible people have attached themselves like leeches to every part of our society; from video game development to book publishing to movie studios to toy companies to restaurants, to grocery stores. It feels like there's nowhere you can go anymore that you're not putting money directly in the hands of the worst pieces of filth that our species has ever shat into existence.
So then it becomes the exhausting game you play with yourself of 'which company is objectively bad ENOUGH for me to distance myself, and which ones can I put up with, or which ones do I have no choice but to put up with?'
I already cut out any future purchases of EA products because of the Saudi/Trump deal. I try to avoid Ubisoft just because.. you know.. they're shitbags to their employees. I tried to keep up with all the companies guilty of using crunch to get games out, because that's awful and I hate it. But that also ended up being basically every video game studio that isn't a few of the small indie guys (and even they do it, they just do it to themselves, so.... that's okay... I guess?).
I do already have Game Pass. I've had it forever. It's saved me tons of money mostly because of my son. He plays so many games. I found it was cheaper to get Game Pass and PS+ than to even attempt to buy every game he wants to play (most of which he plays for a day or two and loses interest after being DESPERATE to play it for the entire month leading up to release). At the same time, I do still buy tons of games, so it won't kill him if we get rid of Game Pass. Definitely something I need to mull over.