altcunningham
Hooker with a heart of gold
The tiering is about what I would do. I have the reissued Spidey without the Peter head and I would put him on the low end of excellent, simply because he's one of my all-time fidget figures.That's fair, though I still regard many of them as excellent. I'd tier the ones I own/have owned like this:
I didn't go full complete with hush, I mostly wanted the family and a couple key villains. But there's something about the likenesses that are a tad soft, and you mentioned the proportions.
I think my top two would be Nightwing for overall action figure goodness and Ivy just for stepping off the page.
I've said it a lot in other threads here, but my approach to a lot of these figures is they're crooked but they are the only game in town.
It is nice that other game is stepping in.