I have a lot of bones to pick with the line overall but it really has done a good job with Batman rogues. I think the only character I'm openly unhappy with from his classic villains is Clayface because mine fell to pieces out of the box and I didn't care to replace him (and in hand he kind a looked like... something worse than clay). Recent pickups of Scarecrow, Riddler, Two-Face, and Penguin... I'm pretty happy with them all together on a shelf. Wish we got a Catwoman with less of the diaper-y looking design but at least they made my favorite costume of hers.
For consistency's sake, I really hope McF gives us a Silver Age purple-dress Catwoman, before we're done. So many Catwoman looks, it's surprising we haven't gotten more of them.